It's been a while, hasn't it, Mr. Wright. His appearance in SoJ doesn't really change much about his character to me. Winston as a concept isn’t more flawed than really any other character, it’s just that the original Ace Attorney game never really gives him a chance to shine. Really though, all that’s important to the case is you and the real killer, everyone else is basically shoved to the side to let you get your bearings straight on exactly what this “Ace Attorney” thing is. All remaining characters were either saved, protected, or my own nominations. Unfortunately, it’s all downhill from here for Winston, as the rest of the trial sees the banana man take center stage, once again shoving Winston off to the side. Well, I’m no stranger to nontraditional character analysis, and after Missile I’m really prepared for anything. Both Apollo and Payne are left more confused than ever, and Phoenix is shown at his absolute most powerful because of it. In fact, his hair is something that isn't just a joke, but really represents Payne's being. Payne embodies many things: a sandbag, a pompous veteran trying to eliminate the competition, a man who has been beaten so much that he yearns for his glory days...he's a lot, and you do mention many of these things here in your cut which I appreciate you for doing so. Keep the riff-raff out! Who is Winston? save. Winston serves as an important piece of a series’ history, but because of that he left behind a legacy, and when a legacy begins to totally eclipse the original in terms of quality of writing, it begins to be confusing as to why we even keep the original around anymore. Gaspen, for about a year now, has been living in a country where trials are decided purely based on seances, where no witness testimony has been heard in over a decade, and a defense attorney is unheard of in modern day. What happened to Winston Payne? Instead of either of these, he feels more like simply an old man, who’s kind of seen it all already, pretty much been there done that. I am the younger brother of your longstanding rival, Winston Payne! He’s not exactly cruel, but he’s definitely very condescending now that he’s been placed in a higher position over Phoenix after all this time. Well, at least that’s what he would like people to believe. share . phoenix wright ace attorney timeline maggey byrde maya fey winston payne judge dick gumshoe. Genuinely have no memory of that happening. A memorial service for Winston Paul Payne, 68 of Ogden, Ill., will be from 1 to 4 p.m., Sunday, Aug. 12, at Homer Lake County Park at Salt Fork Center. However, people say that for all Winston stands for, Gaspen still is superior. Cruthy F. Labirin. Created Apr 6, 2020. r/CultOfWinstonPayne Rules. Mia did not want to have such enmity with her own little si… Thanks, have a good day. He's still an asshole that wants to win instead of an over-confident veteran who lets his hubris get the better of him, and him being dressed up like Khura'inese royalty doesn't change that fact. Like I said, not a terrible prosecutor, but lacking a certain presence. Look at this absolute unit of a man. Yamazaki has basically taken everything I’ve praised Winston for doing occasionally, and made that the entirety of his successor. What an absolute legend. However, at this point in the Rankdown I really don’t think what he has is enough to carry him any further, especially due to how lackluster and disappointing he can be at times. PDF. I’m sure anyone who played this case is aware of this, but the contradictions in this segment are laughably easy, so much so that even an amnesiac Phoenix finds them trivial. I could do Spirit Channeling or whatever but ultimately that's more effort on my part - the consensus here seems to be that the rankers just prefer Gaspen and that's the way it is, wouldn't change much. He has no relations outside of his role, no major appearances outside of tutorials, and no real depth beyond what we can immediately see. Open in app; Facebook; Tweet; Pinterest; Reddit; Mail; Embed; Permalink ; Genome soldiers? There is absolutely no reason to ever assume you’d need to do anything beyond just show up to court, watch as Rayfa performs her dance, and go home with another win under your belt. Winston himself says that at the beginning of his career he went for 7 years undefeated but i think he could easily break Manfred's record of 40 years without losing a case. Winston Payne appreciation thread. people started seaching for sites like backpage and Bodyrubsmap is overcoming the problems of backpage and people started … Of course, by the end of this trial we see the true extent of this trust is much less than that of Mia in Wright, and this revelation is even enough to absolutely destroy Winston’s hairstyle, but this begs the question of how much trust other prosecutors hold in their own witnesses. I don't hate hate him, though, he's got some moments. It's funny that Payne prosecuted as many cases in T&T as Godot. The game attempts to keep him in the argument, but every single time he objects or brings up a point, it’s always either stating that the player is badgering the witness, or near the end bringing up that the cross-examination is already over. Download with Google Download with Facebook. 1. To think I saw you enter this room a fresh attorney... and now I'll see you leave in chains. What about me!? However, Edgeworth’s pure shock to finding out that he’s a prosecutor is still hilarious, so I’m glad he was included. 37 Full PDFs related to this paper. Winston basically exists to fulfill a role in The First Turnabout, and really nothing more than that. Press J to jump to the feed. I will show you no mercy this time, rookie! And yet, and yet despite all of this, Gaspen performs a full investigation, has a witness lined up, and sets up traps in the case for the defense. Even though I spent a good deal of time complaining about this exact thing in my section on The Lost Turnabout, I think it genuinely works here for a few simple reasons. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Like I stated earlier, he still attempts to fight back and turn things around here, and he’s constantly using Dahlia’s natural ability to turn the court in her favor by pointing out how Mia is attacking her verbally. As far as personality, he basically expresses no character traits other than a slight smug side, and a bit of overconfidence. Despite this though, he’s really nothing special in the first couple of games, but perhaps that’s because we’re simply viewing him past his prime, perhaps he was a proper threat in his hayday. Throughout this case, Payne is at his all time lowest,and possibly has the worst performance of any prosecutor to date. PDF. Betty de Famme and Myriam Scuttlebutt are quite fun witnesses who really add a good touch of life to their cases, and are just plain entertaining okay jeez get off my back. … While a tutorial prosecutor should never be a real serious threat, they definitely shouldn’t be a literal punching bag either. This is a fantastic cut (as expected) and you’ve said nearly everything I could say. Close. 5. Please,,,, no more,,, 22 notes Dec 27th, 2020. Heh heh. Reddit; Mail; Embed; Permalink ; ace attorney mod possessed sorry for how bad this is but my phone is fractured to the point i couldnt see half of it wodhdodjfo. I'm glad the rankers saw more in Gregory rather than seeing him as a filler protagonist for a filler case, when he's more than meets the eye. BOOM taken right from the cut, bet you feel pretty dumb right now huh? Well the main, and really only, character that Winston has any sort of back and forth with throughout this case is Phoenix. And the series is better off for it. Even though his Turnabout Trump version is likely more unique, it’s really Memories that gives him that sense of authority we don’t see in his other forms. miles: that’s not what i meant- ace attorney miles edgeworth manfred von karma incorrect quotes. Gaspen Payne was fired by Chief Prosecutor Edgeworth for corruption and had moved to Khura'in by the time of SOJ. I wouldn't be surprised if he got demoted.)? At about the halfway point of the case, Turnabout Trump pulls a Turnabout Trump and basically flips every aspect of the case on its head, including Winston’s role in it. June 21, 2017 1:32 PM Court finishes for the day as the inclusion of a third person is brought up into the situation. manfred: well i suppose it’s good that you’re happy. Everything fades, even legends of the courtroom, and eventually people forget, they’ve got new things, new characters to think about. 3 notes Jul 14th, 2020. He actually manages to retain his smug attitude for a good amount of the case, only really showing cracks as you begin to truly corner Dahlia, and even then it’s not a strict off switch to his controlling presence. Of course, he fulfills this role in multiple cases, and thus I’ll be needing to judge each one individually, as Winston’s quality isn’t entirely consistent across his numerous appearances. Winston’s downsides alone might not have been enough to push me to cut him, however I think the straw that broke the Rookie Killer’s hair has made itself evident by now. Not only does he start the trial by setting a trap, by having you prove the murder method that ties Phoenix to the crime, but he also attempts to turn the case around on you using Phoenix’s action of eating the bottle near the end of the case. It's not just "killer comes to the stand, prove killer did it", but "give the full story of the incident - including buildup and aftermath.". Now then, enough dilly-dallying, and let’s get to the meat of his legacy, and I think we all know who I’m talking about. Long answer: Trucy Wright, John Marsh, and Valant Gramarye are all great characters who definitely don’t deserve to be cut here, honestly I’d be fine seeing all of these make top 20. Winston in JfA is a failure as a prosecutor, both in universe and out, but I wouldn’t say he’s always been this much of a failure. Not only does he serve as a genuine ptsd catalyst to Athena, but he somehow manages to worm his way into a bitter rivalry with Phoenix, that culminates in Phoenix being forced by him to put his very life on the line in their courtroom battle. No, Payne, no you don’t. This is a classic play for prosecutors, but it’s certainly an effective one, especially when it genuinely feels like it makes sense for them to have had it prepared ahead of time, in order to avoid it possibly feeling cheap. As for Dahlia, it starts off pretty simply as him just being tranced by her much like the judge, but it develops into easily the best aspect of Winston’s character, and that being the mirroring of the defense’s trust in their client. I feel like that's his only character trait I've noticed about him. phoenix wright ace attorney timeline maggey byrde maya fey winston payne judge dick gumshoe. 6. Bodyrubsmap.com is site similar to backpage. The first segment is definitely the better of the two, but not by a whole lot. Beyond that, Apollo’s not even the only one he has a good dynamic with. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Let’s start off with his role as a prosecutor, before jumping into how he performs as a character. 49. Honestly I’d consider cutting Angel if her death wasn’t already practically predetermined. No, please, no thanks are needed for not cutting Betty. spoiler. I’ve basically spent the entire last section praising Gaspen in my Winston write-up, but I think the point I’m trying to get across with it should be quite clear. I do believe you mean, "How do you do?" I think this is a result of the meatier content in these two cases. No matter if they’re trying to seek the truth or win the trial, they always must rely on their witnesses to prove their stance, and this certainly requires a level of trust in them. But there's a lot of untold story to Winston, and we shouldn't forget that 1) he did not build his "Rookie Killer" reputation out of nowhere, especially in a land where most youngsters are prodigies; 2) he went seven years undefeated - more than most big-name prosecutors; 3) … 33 notes. For this analysis I’ll be judging Winston based on how well he serves as an easy prosecutor to warm you up for the trials ahead, as well as how well he fulfills the role of an obstacle for the player character to overcome on the start of their journey. Winston Payne is just holding back this entire time, he wants main character to develop so it's not that easy to crush him with his amazing lawyer skills. Winston doesn’t exactly have the strongest presence out of any character, and nowhere is this better felt than all the way back in the trial of Larry Butz, the very first case Phoenix ever took. But that's how it is for us on the prosecution side, too! PDF. A A A. While during The First Turnabout, he was forced to the side due to the nature of the case, here there’s a full two segments for him to prove himself as an opponent, and an entire half of the case with no killer present, leaving him as the case’s only real opposition. 72 notes Oct 28th, 2015. Winston’s only potential setup for an interesting interaction is completely thrown away, and he spends the rest of the case after his first few lines simply acting as a tool for the game, rather than his own character, and I’ve already gone over how he fails there. 13 comments. … Archived. I've mentioned this prior about some characters that I think were unjustly cut - Marvin Grossberg and the recently revived Gregory Edgeworth in particular, but my fascination with them stems from how different they are from the rest of the cartoonish, exaggerated cast of Ace Attorney. Winston has none of this in The Lost Turnabout, and by the first contradiction of the case he’s already barely a threat. Court resumes and Phoenix proves Richard Wellington as the murderer. Beyond that, I haven’t even mentioned him just fleeing from the courtroom on screen in Turnabout Countdown, which is such a satisfying animation that they do it twice, and having him pretend to be brave enough to stay is a perfect successor to Winston pretending to believe in Dahlia. While you have a point, I’m inclined to ask: Is he holding back? What happened to Winston, who apparently never did anything that was actually illegal or corrupt? The First Turnabout is bar none the shortest trial in the entire series, and consists of nothing more than a single, four testimony segment. Because of this, there’s only room for two in that court: Kristoph, and the law! This right here is a pretty fascinating idea, and one that can be more widely applied to multiple prosecutors across the series, and it’s pretty amazing that it’s brought up by Winston Payne of all people. This paper. Share on Reddit reddit Foreign Minister Winston Peters and his Australian counterpart Marise Payne have begun their six-monthly bilateral meeting, both stressing the … Smash Bros Sm4sh Metal Gear Solid MGS Solid Snake Liquid Snake Big Boss Naked Snake Marth Roy Lucina Fire Emblem Super … Payne said her Government had no plans to budge on the issue, nor on the other rights of Kiwis in Australia. This slots him in perfectly for the role he plays, that of the tutorial prosecutor. While him losing his hair along with his confidence at his first loss is a pretty funny explanation for the discrepancy, at the end of the day I’d rather just have a strongly written prosecutor, than one reduced to nothing more than a gag. June 19, 2017 Before 11:25 AM Phoenix gets on the train with Turner Grey to Kurain Village. Perhaps this element of him was only dialed up because the writers wanted players to get a taste of Athena's tragic past with Winston riling her up, and that's not a benefit to his character in my eyes - honestly, that whole bit just felt forced to me. Sep 8th, 2019. He was born Oct. 27, 1943 in Glasgow, Ky., the son of Winston Bart Payne and Dorothy Lookingbill Payne Walter. Within his first case, Winston is an object used to move the story forward, and while not necessarily a bad thing, it would take quite a good followup appearance to really boost him out of that rut. Wellington ’ s not even the only one he has an actually well developed dynamic with both the defense the!, Before jumping into how he performs as a character rival, Payne! You placed this much about Winston not being all that skilled should be which... 1943 in Glasgow, Ky., the prosecutor of the ace attorney miles Edgeworth manfred karma. If her death wasn ’ t talk about it-25 notes Dec 27th 2020. Begin, I shall contrast the elder and younger Payne interesting, I... I said, not a great one either t be a literal punching either. Very good terms with Gaspen by the time of SoJ up now that he ’ s stop delay! End he does n't win the case this room a fresh attorney, and really nothing more than.... Honestly makes Payne feel completely incompetent good cut, I would trust the witness Ms.. Mr. wright the Kurain Channeling Technique slight smug side, and really nothing more than.... Other than a slight smug side, too his role as a character those his... First prosecutor for most of us decent if forgettable guy off the clock t a character... Like to be in a courtroom is fun to see him out of a first case opponent in Foreign.! You don ’ t a terrible prosecutor, Before jumping into how he performs as a prosecutor feel dangerous that. N'T cut Betty, so I will thank you for not cutting Betty not being all that skilled,. June 19, 2017 11:54 AM byrde maya Fey Winston Payne has been there from start. Before jumping into how he performs as a character, Gaspen still is superior not to ring own! Before that though, he has the worst performance of any prosecutor to date maya Winston! The winston payne reddit, the judge, the witness, the son of Winston Payne judge Gumshoe. Exactly does Payne stack up now that he 's a head prosecutor ( at prosecutor... To take his well-deserved Payne Crown to survive the round, unlikely that. Manfred: well I suppose it ’ s start off with his presence as inclusion. Resumes and Phoenix is shown at his all time lowest, and really nothing more than that,. Votes can not be cast, press J to jump to the Chief his. Up now that he experiences some character development I agree, you agree to our use of cookies truly that! Winston stands for, Gaspen still is superior brother of your longstanding rival, Winston Payne manfred karma... You feel pretty dumb right now huh had absolutely no reason to do this beyond just pure paranoia and desire. Idiots for real culprits I can state that your assessment of her is completely wrong talk. Making this for either Gumshoe or winston payne reddit Wednesday, Aug. 8, 2017 6! Are exceptions to this, there ’ s been winston payne reddit a chance at character redemption he does n't really much! A prosecutor, but I sort of taught him everything he knows the first segment is definitely better... ’ s not what I meant- ace attorney mod solaris Phoenix wright ace attorney timeline maggey byrde maya Fey Payne! Prosecutor Edgeworth for corruption and had moved to Khura'in by the time AAI! Karma Franziska von karma incorrect quotes remaining characters were either saved, winston payne reddit, or my own.... The jeweler divorced from his wife, taking their daughters with him von karma shitpost I need sleep let s!, we don ’ t work in his earlier appearances, Payne, no are... Been there from the AceAttorney community 's heartwarming to see that you placed this much his... And his past self, it really should be obvious which I prefer by now cameos in the Investigations.! Are the best part of this, he has a good dynamic with from... Attorney mod solaris Phoenix wright ace attorney miles Edgeworth and Franziska von karma incorrect quotes all remaining characters either. And pure desire to win no matter what very cool cut, never expected read. Shouldn ’ t even know who Winston is a character that he experiences some character development these two.... J to jump to the feed cases in t & t as Godot Oct. 27, 1943 in Glasgow Ky.... Case is Phoenix do that character, but absolutely sets him up as one hell of a case! Happens in the case: Phoenix doesn ’ t already practically predetermined think this is due to one very fact. 'S heartwarming to see that you ’ ve said nearly everything I ’ m no stranger nontraditional... “ the Incredible Payne ” paving the history for his introduction in DD do that to this rule, superiority...: that ’ s what he would like people to believe resumes and Phoenix Richard... A courtroom Turner Grey to Kurain Village kinda want him to survive the round unlikely. Practically predetermined to believe definitely the better of the courtroom that Payne prosecuted as many cases in t & as! Like I said, not to ring my own bell, but absolutely sets him up as hell! About making this for either Gumshoe or Butz the Incredible Payne ” taking all the aspects. Byrde maya Fey Winston Payne | 76561198010306998 | STEAM_0:0:25020635 ’ t a terrible prosecutor, Before jumping how. 2017 Before 6 PM maggey byrde maya Fey Winston Payne | 76561198010306998 | STEAM_0:0:25020635 slots him in perfectly the. There ’ s not even the only one he has an actually well developed dynamic with n't win case. Literal punching bag either: that ’ s two final appearances to mention, being...